By Sarah Ryley
Reprinted from Brooklyn Daily Eagle
Oct. 19, 2006
BROOKLYN -- Condo hotels are one of the hottest new trends in real estate. In the three years since the first was built in south Florida, at least 115 have been built or are under construction in premiere cities around the world, with one glaring omission? New York.
Donald Trump would build the first if his proposed 45-story luxury condo-hotel is approved for a location a few blocks away from SoHo, in a Greenwich Village manufacturing district that permits only conventional hotels.
His project has Brooklyn leaders in Williamsburg, Greenpoint and Red Hook concerned that it could set a precedent for other real estate developers looking for a "back door" around zoning regulations in their hard-fought manufacturing districts.
"Chelsea and Greenwich are hot areas; Greenpoint and Williamsburg are hot areas, too," said Brian T. Coleman, CEO of the Greenpoint Manufacturing Design Center. "It's not off the charts to say that someone may be willing to attempt to do the same thing here."
He said the hard-fought Williamsburg-Greenpoint rezoning passed in 2005 protected manufacturers, the majority of whom rent, from the pressure they or their landlords were getting to convert industrial buildings into far more lucrative residential units.
Joel Greene, a condo-hotel broker for Condo Hotel Center, said a "source who said he's with the people doing the finances on the project" told him yesterday afternoon that Trump project will break ground on Nov. 1 and kick off sales on Nov. 15.
"They do have permits to do some demolition and some work, but no building permit has been issued," said Tori Edmiston, press secretary for the NYC Department of Buildings. She said the department is also working with the Department of City Planning "to consider appropriate enforcement measures."
This would come as a surprise to the elected officials and activists opposing the 246 Spring St. Trump project, who when interviewed this week were under the impression that the matter was still caught up in a zoning debate.
That's because city zoning regulations permit only transient hotels in manufacturing districts, not residential ones with tenants staying in units for more than 29 consecutive days. Greene said he's unaware of any condo-hotels in manufacturing districts, and that to his knowledge they are all zoned as residential units.
Part Hotel, Part Condo
Condo hotels are part condominium, part hotel and part time share. The units are owned by individuals, who receive all the amenities of a four- or five-star hotel, including concierge and room service.
When the owners aren't using their condo, they turn the keys over to a management service that rents out the unit and gives the owners a portion of the money, which can be used to offset the mortgage, for example.
Rachael Raynoff, press secretary for the Department of City Planning, said the department recognizes that "the condo-hotel model may present an enhanced risk of unlawful residential occupancy," and is working with Buildings to clarify what constitutes a transient use and how to enforce the residential restriction.
Greene said he regularly gets inquiries about condo-hotels in New York, and has a VIP waiting list of over 100 people wanting the first shot at making an offer on the Greenwich Village property.
He said the location for Trump's "SoHo" project is unique because "most condo-hotels are built in oceanfront resorts, Las Vegas strip, downtown areas, like downtown Miami and downtown Chicago," not manufacturing districts, even though SoHo is one of the city's hottest addresses.
And, Greene said he expects the units to start in the low $800,000s, whereas "the average investor is looking to invest around $300,000."
When asked if he could foresee less expensive condo-hotel units selling in some of Brooklyn's hip neighborhoods, like Williamsburg, he responded, "You put Donald Trump's name on it and I could sell it in Haiti."
Andrew Berman, executive director of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, said, "[Trump] knows if he is able to build here, it will utterly transform the neighborhood by opening the door for other condo-hotels to be built in this neighborhood. And he knows that the same thing could happen to other desirable manufacturing districts throughout the city."
Hot Trend Still Cool in New York
Sheldon Greene, CEO of Condo Hotel Center, said he was a little mystified as to why the hot trend has been so "slow and coming to New York City."
While condo hotels are most popular in places like Florida, Las Vegas, Dubai and the Caribbean, they're also big in places like Toronto and Chicago. "A lot of people who live in the suburbs and who frequent Chicago like to have a place of their own. We can give you a four- of five-star hotel, and when you don't want it we can put it in the rental program," he said.
He said, "It's hard to dispute Donald Trump's choice of locations, the guy is a visionary. Maybe he senses that [the Greenwich Village manufacturing district] is a coming area, and maybe it's not the way he wants it now, but it will be one day in the future."